Showing posts with label robots. Show all posts
Showing posts with label robots. Show all posts

Saturday, February 1, 2025

Infrastructuring AI in the Postcolony

The root of all evil is a premature policy optimization.

In the few decades of the history of computing in India there have been some spurts of proactivity, but by and large other than a large bodyshop in IT, we have been comfortable in a mode largely reactive to global developments, with an industry making negligible contribution to computing technologies. Just after liberalisation, C. R. Subramanian had undertaken a long-view analysis of the matter in his "India and The Computer" - with many of his suggestions ringing true to folks in AI today. Let me therefore reconstruct below the difficulties that were noted over 30 years ago for large scale "harmonious development" (not support and maintainance) of computing and software products in India:

1. The domestic markets in India are too small. To make a mark, we've to address the international high-technology demand, which means society being at the cutting-edge of technology and R&D. Considering quick internet based distribution, open-sourcing and market standardisation, any catch-up oriented strategy would have to fight against strong network effects as well. This will be very hard for domestic industry to do in presence of established foreign competition without some protections until they reach a certain stage of technological and business maturity. 

2. Subramanian clearly recommends 'standardisation first' to be one possible technology strategy, but he also says, "...there is a total lack of concern for this at the highest levels of the administration. Political support has not even been sought for this vital step." Based on my own interactions with the Bureau of Indian Standards and other IT sector actors, 30 years later Subramanian's characterisation of embedding political vision in India's technical standardisation strategy has not changed much. Stock policy formats of "one nation one..." lack compatibility with global standardization environment - one way to address this would be to dissociate IT standards from BIS (which comes under Consumer Affairs) and give it directly to MeitY and technology industry stakeholders bodies who have skin in the game.

3. He says, "the private sector in India does not traditionally invest in high-risk, new technology areas." One of the main reasons for this, perhaps owing to our socialist traditions, is that the industry actors (at least the smaller ones) are not seen with much trust and respect. Hans-Peter Brunner notes that 1984 was perhaps the first time since independence when domestic industry actors in India were given on paper a “respectful place”. The little industry guy is not really accorded the respect of a 'partner' in public-private interactions, not to mention of the babu expectations of profound subservience. Resultingly, the industry has stuck to relatively risk averse and by-the-book activities, having neither the financial incentives nor the resourcefulness for high-technology risks/innovation. 

4. Infrastructural ownership, he says is a "must from the point of view of national security and related developments in the space and defense areas. To allow the World Bank a say in the matter is inviting foreign interference in domestic technology aspirations related to self-reliance." Considering our situation in the semiconductor supply chains and an unwritten policy to export brains (the human infrastructure), and now also with data and platforms, who really has digital infrastructural ownership in India?

5. He notes that the "inconsistency in the various policies — fiscal, licensing, technology development and technology import - prevent harmonious development". The natural evangelist of technology in government anywhere is the military, which faces a policy conundrum in India between satisfying its immediate requirements for finished products vs sticking it out for the development of the "indigenous" industry - unless in view of Atmanirbharta it could take a more strategic role in domestic technology sector. I may remind the reader here that the true union of science with industry happened only in the WWII, which in the US resulted into a cultural osmosis where the military picked up management perspectives and businesses picked up military ones.            

But how soon can these difficulties be overcome? In a world where technology infrastructures are often intermingled with social and political imaginations, a mere exorcism by diplomacy and public relations cannot address India's currently vacuous strategy for technological leadership. Our national security as well as digital technology governance being run predominantly through a policing lense has not halped our cause either. Firstly, I must say that it is not the technical but the management standards in our organisations (including govt and startups) which need to catch up with the engineering talent.   

Thence, the AI hype can be appealing to broken institutions - and can lead quickly into a procurement mentality where run-of-the-mill, off-the-shelf analytics and interaction products (even LLMs wrapped into brands) are acquired in the name of promoting and enabling the AI research ecosystem. That is like getting a website made to enable the development of future internet. Shoppers have to shop, but without deeply trusting your own people, letting them not go, and persevering with them on novel ideas, the technological catch-up would not end very soon. Perhaps it is also time for us to deploy legally a broader definition of CSR finance to include certain kinds of R&D as well.

Consider also, that organisational innovations are needed to integrate technology as a doctrinal component at the highest levels. We do not need an "AI policy" as much as we need to formulate a multi-stakeholder industrial policy that integrates and addresses different sector-specific demands (and expectations) of deploying automation, data processing and cyber security. This is a must for national competitiveness, security and defense, and cannot simply be exorcised by witty diplomats.  

Mbembe writes on his experience in postcolonial Africa, that often the actual development of infrastructure has more to do with access to government contracts and rewarding patron-client networks, and not its technical function or nuances - and some note that "this is why roads disappear, factories are built but never operated and bridges go to nowhere"- as we might sometimes relate as well. Now imagine a super-intelligent AI being developed and deployed in the purview of a similar organisational paradigm. If that is the sovereign national discretion, so be it, but it might be useful to make available trustworthy infrastructural components - standardised and open building blocks, both logical and physical, that can be integrated (and disintegrated) at base/local levels as required by anyone - as the local is not very far from the global here - for pure technology competition, for all practical purposes, implies an overall escalation of force with non-lethal effects.  


Saturday, June 11, 2022

A Networked Peace

"To live effectively is to live with adequate information."
 
Norbert Weiner had maintained that nature has an inherent tendency to degrade the organized. The organism, according to him, is opposed to death and disintegration "as message is to noise" - postulating a perpetual conflict between the self-organising and the organised. This is evident everywhere. Take, for example, the rules based world order. The thing about complex adaptive systems is that given their tendencies towards self-organisation, they generally find a way to work around any and all rules. The former then has to reassert itself to turn the self-organising into the organised, as long as it can. Thus the first secretary general of NATO had defined peace as keeping the Russians out, the Americans in, and the Germans down - and the secretary general of NATO today would continue to insist upon the same peace. But undoubtedly in an arena staged upon competing networks, one man's peace is bound to become another's war and vice versa.    
 
Notwithstanding, how do we ensure that in this struggle between the self-organising and the organised, a structure evolves and not destructs. Mr. Weiner had suggested that since all organisations are held together by communication, effective communication engineering is the key to steering society in a purposeful direction. Communication effects control. That is indeed the most fundamental insight of cybernetics, whose father understood society only through the study of the messages and communication facilities which belong to it. Thus the way to create a social structure is to restrict and regulate the information flows in that society, to destroy that structure is to destroy or divert those information flows, i.e. create new information flows. That is what the internet did too.
 
Enter digital networks and artificial agents. The internet hasn't lived upto the expectations of the founders of computing. JCR Licklider, for example, had prophesied that in the information age, unemployment would disappear from the face of the earth because of the opportunities offered by "an infinite crescendo of on-line interactive debugging". Seems unlikely to happen. A lot of the computing giants couldn't foresee the future that their dream machine, AI, would bring aboard while the humanity, globally and gently, sleepwalks into an era of perpetual warring and a painful transformation of the nation-state.
 
In 2011, a startup named Pacific Social Architecting Corporation, figured if they could change these information flows using online socialbots, they'd be able to alter the social architecture of a community. They tried and while their experiments met with some success, their startup did not. Almost two decades later, researchers writing for Nature Communications describe the use of similar software agents to produce "information gerrymandering" - forcing an asymmetric assortment of influence over an unsuspecting population and creating the majority illusion for specific nodes. Even in their highly-cited paper on social botnets, Yazan Boshmaf and others had suggested early on that each social bot in an online social network is going to be capable of two kinds of influence operations - those related to social interaction, and those related to the social structure. And we are only now witnessing the true meaning of that. To think about it, using networks of bots to create a very elaborate deception, even military deception, looks fairly doable with present developments in natural language and image processing. Unsurprisingly, some researchers did gone ahead and demonstrated the use of a guided social botnet to infiltrate and cultivate specific employees of targeted organisations(!).
 
Since communication effects control, the problem of Command and Control (C2) of operating such social machines becomes a problem of architecting a resilient and credible flow of information to effect specific organisational behaviours. The older methods of botnet command and control are no longer even suitable in this environment, as the use of social networks inevitable brings in a P2P architecture (i.e. each software agent can send encrypted commands to the rest of the network). We are thus seeing some very interesting C2 designs when it comes to bot deployments - from the use of smart contracts and blockchain to implement the C2 to embedding bot commands into Bitcoin transactions, we seem to be headed for interesting times in the cyberspace. To anyone still skeptical, do checkout this report on an IoT botnet that not just hacks your networked devices but also creates and operates socialbots using that infrastructure, even including a Machine Learning component that can be turned on or off depending upon the human users' responses on social media platforms.
 
Other than coordinating the bot network, identifying and prioritising the human users to reach using bots is also another challenge. These days, digital social networks enable a large number of unintended users to join an unfolding event i.e. the ongoing Russo-Ukrainian conflict. To those having to watch random networks form and dissolve from the existing scale free asymmetric networks of our modern human existence, following things must be highlighted about the human network to manipulate this "network-centric" environment:  
     -Which nodes have the decision rights?
     -What nodal decision rights can be accessed using software agents?
     -What is the pattern of interaction between these and other nodes?
     -What kind of inflow-outflow of information emerges from these networks? 

Coming back to the 1992 social architecting experiment, a key question that arises is whether such strategic use of software agent networks can overturn the importance of the existing key nodes in the human digital networks today? The key nodes are the information junctions, a kind of intelligence device within the network. Being at the junction, these nodes have power to regulate information flows, directly affecting a lot of other nodes, which also gives these a disproportionate amount of power over the rest of the network. It must be noted here how the information domain comes into a very intimate embrace with the cognitive and the political domains.

The original software robot was designed to provide an integrated and expressive interface to the internet as well as to change its behavior and choice of actions in response to transient system conditions. A coordinating network of such programs acting socially brings to table an important non-human agency in human affairs. Since computers today "record, relay, represent and inform our responses" to almost all political-military-economic conflicts as they unfold - today's digital networks potentially enable much coercive and destructive potential in the hands of robots. Our digital societies, as well as the their dominant military-industrial-media networks, both face the everyday dangers of interconnectivity i.e. networked terrorism, recurrent misinformation cascades, and computer/biological viruses to name a few. As Buddha used to say, everything is interconnected and life is suffering. In retrospect, it is a tribute to Turing that “bot or not” is turning into one of the defining questions of our hyper-connected age as the animal and the machine networks slowly renegotiate the structure of a new peace.

P.S. Credits to Scott Wolcott for the inspiration.
 

Saturday, September 29, 2018

On Rewards

"Any rational society would either kill me or give me my books." 
-Hannibal

Society only tolerates a certain kind of deviance, the kind that has a great or novel expectation of rewards. AI engineers too reflect these tendencies when treating that certain kind of deviance in agents as a refreshing intelligent behavior, given that it is rewarding to the larger interests. A rudimentary example of this could be a bipedal robot figuring out the use of his hands when the walk involves a steep climb by imitating what it observes in other agents, biological and otherwise. As it is, in swarm the most critical information is always coming from the nearest agents which are also considered to be the most reliable. In humans at least, learning does not always lead to a permanent change of behavior, expectation of rewards and fear of punishments often puts us onto the path of overlooking or even misinterpreting our learnings. Yet while the discovery of which response leads to what effect goes far beyond just observations, observational learning is said to be the most prominent method of learning. It should be evident therefore that the attention control mechanism and a hyper-sensitive selection of stimulus and response can make the difference between a satisfactory outcome and the optimal one.

Unlike naturally occuring intelligence, Artificial Intelligence gets its teeth mostly from nurture, as 'nature' mostly applies to its embodiment and hardware limitations. The case of human multitasking is an interesting study in the nurturing of intelligent behavior. A productive use of downtime fetches a much higher reward value than leisure and inertia. We have effective attention mechanisms to cope with long & complex inputs, we apply controlled attention and carry out continuous switching between tasks to maximize rewards. Our perceptual motor expertise gets better with the task familiarity and an economic attentional distribution is then either always rewarded or is at least never punished. More than that, we consistently acquire new goals and build a hierarchy of goals (correlating with hierarchy of needs) which helps us to multitask better and organize our time and life towards greater reward expectancy.

Now if we are to have agents with the ability to acquire new goals on their own, operating under a predetermined hierarchy of goals based on a cause-effect relationship, AI will need a more purposeful nature of being which risks an even willful acceptance of punishments (or negative rewards) towards the greater goal. A finer sentiment sensitivity, a clear demarcation between mission-specific-sensing and non-mission-specific-sensing, and a causality based actuation that draws from dynamic sets of rules seems to be the way forward.

Any finite set of rules, as frames and boxes generally go, is bound to provide an incomplete approximation of reality. As some philosophers have noted, instinct is the most intelligent among all forms of intelligence, and it is least bound by the concerns and deliberations of rewards and punishments as compared to the non-instinctive actions. With more and more seamless and direct coupling of perception to action and an incomplete knowledge-base like humans, sometimes agents too, like humans, can run into a quagmire best described by a remark which Napoleon had made after losing the war in Russia, that, between the sublime to the ridiculous is one short step. Bonne Guerre.

---